Monday, 10 December 2018
IOP Report {No. 2 for November 2017} Print
Saturday, 11 November 2017
While Occupation and blockade are business as usual for Israel,

there should be no business with Israel

In Occupied Palestine

Zionism in practice

Israel’s Daily Toll on Palestinian Life, Limb, Liberty and Property

(Compiled by Leslie Bravery, Palestine Human Rights Campaign, Auckland, New Zealand [If you have difficulty with the display of this report, it may be better viewed on our website]

NB: We shall always do our utmost to verify the accuracy of all items in these IOP newsletters/reports wherever possible – but please forgive us for any errors or omissions (not of our own making) that may occur! L & M.

IOP Report {Number 2 for November 2017}

Millions earmarked for

settler roads

in Occupied West Bank

Israel retains, as

bargaining chips,

bodies of 5 Palestinians

killed in Gaza bombing

John Kerry:

"No one among the

Israeli leaders

wants peace"

Australia: It's not about the Holocaust. What has the Holocaust got to do with questioning whether Josh Frydenberg holds Hungarian citizenship? ("Citizenship 'witch hunt' must end: PM" November 3). Does Malcolm Turnbull seriously think questioning Mr Frydenberg's citizenship is anti-Semitism, as his emotional outburst asserts during his press conference? The fact the Nazis stripped Mr Frydenberg's mother of her citizenship does not make her not a Hungarian national, and for Mr Turnbull to also deny her Hungarian nationality is exactly what the Nazis aimed to do. Germany and other European countries have compensated and restored citizenship to their Jewish nationals long ago and many Jews who left have returned to Germany and their former countries. Mr Turnbull's and Mr Frydenberg's use of the Holocaust and Nazi crimes against Jews to attack and blackmail those who have legitimate questions of dual citizenship, as they questioned non-Jews, is just lunacy. Financial Review Ali Kazak.

It’s not just about Occupation. It’s about Zionism. US Campaign for Palestinian Rights | This past June, when we marked 50 years of Israel’s Occupation of the Gaza Strip and West Bank, including East Jerusalem, we were clear that this was one of many important anniversaries in 2017. These include last week’s anniversary of 100 years since the Balfour Declaration and, later this month, 70 years since the UN recommended the partition of Palestine – resulting in the violent displacement of 750,000 Palestinians and denial of their return by Israel. These anniversaries help us understand the intended permanence and totality of Israel’s settler-colonial project – something which Zionist leaders seeking a Jewish state in Palestine spoke about openly. Zionist leaders understood that the only way to manufacture a Jewish majority was to drive out the indigenous Palestinian population and to settle Jewish people in their place. This week, we are releasing a series of powerful graphics, “Zionism is Colonialism: In Their Own Words,” to highlight that Zionism is – and has always been – a settler-colonial project. Israel commonly justifies its oppressive policies in the name of security, but these graphics lay bare the reality that we see on the ground today. The siege of Gaza, the ongoing displacement of Bedouin in the Naqab inside Israel, and the ban on return for millions of Palestinian refugees are all manifestations of Zionism. Early Zionists knew that this would be necessary to create and maintain a Jewish state in a land whose native population was not majority Jewish.

Air Canada terminates main contract with Israel Aerospace Industries.

Thousands take to London's streets for 'equal rights' on the centenary of the creation of Israel.

Netanyahu earmarks millions for settler roads in Occupied West Bank. 7 November 2017 | Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced yesterday that he had earmarked 200 million shekels ($57 million) for settler roads in the Occupied West Bank, Israeli media reported. Netanyahu delivered his remarks to hunger-striking and protesting settlers who had erected a tent in front of his residence, after a meeting with his Finance Minister, Moshe Kahlon. The fund was allocated to complete roads going around the Palestinian city of Qalandiya and near the illegal Israeli settlement of Beit Aryeh in the central Occupied West Bank. During a meeting with settler leaders in October, Netanyahu promised a security package worth 800 million ($228 million) would be part of the 2018 budget. According to the Times of Israel, Netanyahu said that the remaining 600 million ($171 million) for additional bypass routes and lighting would only be added to the 2019 budget. Israeli bypass roads aim to connect the illegal Israeli settlements with each other at the expense of Palestinian farms, homes and other facilities.

Palestine topping UNWTO 2017 list of fastest growing tourism destinations worldwide. The already steady stream of travellers visiting Palestine, whether as individuals or in organised group tours, is expected to rise to new record heights in the course of 2017. For the first half of 2017, the United Nations World Tourism Organisation (UNWTO) announced that Palestine is the fastest growing tourism destination worldwide. More:

UN Weekly Report:

Human rights groups condemn Israeli decision not to return to their families the bodies of 5 Palestinians killed in an Israeli attack.

Jerusalem, a city defined by barriers. Living side-by-side in Jerusalem are communities who exist with no interaction with one another – kept apart by fear, nationalism and religion. To some extent it has long been thus, and not just between Israelis and Palestinians. There is also segregation along secular and ultra-orthodox lines, and the residual hierarchy between Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jews that emerged when Israel was created in 1948. Of the 900,000 residents of Jerusalem, 37% are Palestinians, 32% are ultra-Orthodox Jews and the rest are made up of secular and religious nationalist Jews and the tiny Christian population. More:

Former US Secretary of State John Kerry: “No one among the Israeli leaders wants peace”.

Beyond the Holocaust

Leslie Bravery | 11 November 2017

On 31 October 2017, the Whale Oil website posted a Newshub article featuring a photo of the First Secretary of the Iranian Embassy, Hormoz Ghahremani, below the headline: Complaints laid about Iranian hate speech diplomat. Beneath the photo can be seen a video of a meeting at which Ghahremani was the first guest speaker. A casual visitor to the website might be excused for believing that the Iranian Embassy's First Secretary was guilty of Holocaust denial.

Another speaker at the meeting did, later, question the history of the Nazi Holocaust. However, the article quotes New Zealand historian Professor Paul Moon as saying that diplomats from Iran were “talking about Jewish conspiracies, describing Israel as a cancer that needs to be removed, denying the holocaust”. It should have been made clear that at no point in Hormoz Ghahremani's speech was there the slightest hint of Holocaust denial. The website also reported Moon as saying that Hormoz Ghahremani, talking about terrorism in the Middle East, made “accusations that . . . somehow the Jews were responsible for terrorism.” This is completely untrue, as the video can prove.

Reference to Jews

The only reference Ghahremani made to Jews was when he said:

We believe that the only stable solution to the crisis in Palestine is, putting an end to the Occupation, returning of all Palestinian refugees to their homeland, and allowing Palestinians to decide on their country's future through democratic referendum by respecting the rights of the Muslims, Jews and Christians.”

In an interview with Newshub, Mr Ghahremani thanked the New Zealand Government for playing an active role in co-sponsoring UN Security Council Resolution 2334, which condemns Israel's illegal Occupation settlement policy.

While Israel calls itself a Jewish state, many see it as a state that identifies more with its founding ideology. The signatories to Israel's 1948 Declaration of Independence, identified themselves thus:

. . . We members of the People's Council, representatives of the Jewish Community of Eretz-Israel and of the Zionist movement . . .”

Zionism holds that hostility to Jews is inevitable and that Jews can only be secure through the creation of a Jewish state. So instead of fighting to put an end to all political racism, the ideology resigns itself to what it believes is the inevitability of endless hatred towards Jews. In the process of achieving its territorial ambitions, the Zionist state constantly violates the Fourth Geneva Convention. The result is an intolerable daily toll upon Palestinian life, limb, liberty and property. Not surprisingly, Israel's claim, that its actions are on behalf of world Jewry, is received by Jews opposed to Zionism as a grievous insult. The promoters of Zionism are keen to make all opposition to their ideology appear to be anti-Semitic. Unfortunately, many non-Jews are taken in by this and tiptoe around the issue of Palestinian human rights.

Right of Return

Paul Moon's published views are revealing. On the Balfour Declaration he notes:

For all its brevity, Balfour's Declaration was sufficiently nuanced in its assessment of the national status of different groups in the region to make it clear that it aimed to do what was morally right rather than politically expedient . . .”

The Zionist view that the ethnic cleansing of Palestinians is 'morally right' is exemplified by Israel's Law of Return which enables immigrants from Europe and the United States, who have never had any connection with Palestine, to dispossess the Palestinian people. On the other hand, compounding this injustice, Israel refuses to respect the right of return of Palestinian refugees, which is recognised in international law. The Israel Institute of New Zealand would applaud Paul Moon's justification of Zionist ethnic cleansing. He writes:

It was Balfour's intention that the Jewish people – who were indigenous to Palestine – would have a "national home", while more recent occupiers of the territory were classed as "communities", and thus could have religious and civil rights, but could not claim the same sovereign status in Palestine.”

To put it plainly, the ideology reduces the population of Palestine to the status of “more recent occupiers of the territory” in order to give precedence to settlers from Europe and the United States.

Fawning over British imperialism

Paul Moon tell us that “Britain had confirmed the undeniable right to Jewish sovereignty in Palestine”. His only criticism of Britain is that it failed to enforce the injustice with sufficient force and alacrity. This blind belief that Britain had the moral authority to override the native population's right to sovereignty belongs to a darker past. Moon lectures us that “Israel has emerged triumphantly as a modern, sophisticated, egalitarian, liberal democracy, much like our own.” The truth is that Israel, unlike New Zealand, refuses even to define its borders. The Zionist state introduced nuclear weapons to the Middle East and refuses to sign the nuclear non-proliferation agreement. Israel has been forced to apologise for sending its spies to this country in an attempt to fraudulently obtain New Zealand passports. The mission failed and the spies were put on trial and imprisoned here. This unfriendly behaviour was reflected again when Israel reacted to New Zealand's sponsoring of UNSCR 2334 by describing it as a “declaration of war”.

Paul Moon asserts that Israel is a democracy 'much like' New Zealand but New Zealand strives to conduct its affairs in accordance with international law, whereas Israel has a history that demonstrates quite the opposite.

In 1980, the UN Security Council unanimously adopted Resolution 476, which reaffirmed an earlier UN call for Israel to end its 1967 occupation of Palestinian land. The Resolution confirmed that none of the legislative and administrative measures taken by Israel has legal validity and that they all constitute flagrant violations of the Fourth Geneva Convention. The 9 July 2004 International Court of Justice ruling on the illegality of Israel’s Wall in East Jerusalem and other areas of the West Bank confirmed this.

Holocaust denial

Holocaust denial is often inspired by racism but ignorance also plays a part. The scourge of Nazism was the most horrific state-sponsored tragedy in modern history. Evidence for that is overwhelming; a re-broadcast TV series, World at War (available on DVD), with voice-over by Sir Laurence Olivier, was a recent grim reminder, viewable in New Zealand. While Nazism targeted many races and minorities, Jews were its main obsession. To this day, most people do not despise Germans for the Holocaust, realising that people can so easily be brainwashed, even for long periods, by ideological propaganda. All the more credit then to the wonderful heroism of those Germans who resisted Nazism and risked their own lives and those of their families to shelter Jews from the Nazis.

Resisting ideology

A group calling itself Righteous Jews ( that established itself in 2003 felt that it was a way for its members

to commemorate the memory of those Palestinians who have been, and continue to be depopulated, dispossessed, humiliated, tortured, and murdered in the name of political Zionism and its quest to create a Jewish state in the lands between the Mediterranean and the Jordan River.”

Righteous Jews tells us that its founding was inspired by the website of the Holocaust Museum at Yad Vashem, located on Mount Herzl on the land of the Palestinian village of Ein Karem, 1400 metres south of the ethnically-cleansed Palestinian village of Deir Yassin. Yad Vashem lists the names of non-Jews who risked their lives, freedom and safety in order to rescue one or several Jews from the threat of death or deportation to death camps. For many years, this list was referred to as the list of 'Righteous Gentiles' and is now called 'Righteous Among the Nations'. According to Righteous Jews:

Deir Yassin is as important a part of Jewish, as it is of Palestinian, history. Deir Yassin, coming in April 1948, just three years after the liberation of Auschwitz in January 1945, marks a Jewish transition from enslavement to empowerment and from abused to abuser. Can there ever have been such a remarkable shift, over such a short period, in the history of a people?


Deir Yassin signalled the ethnic cleansing of 750,000 Palestinians, leading to their eventual dispossession and exile and was just one example of a conscious and premeditated plan to destroy the Palestinians as a people in their own homeland.

. . . since the establishment of the state of Israel, successive Israeli governments, whether Labour or Likud, and whether by force as at Deir Yassin, or by chicanery as at Oslo and Camp David, have followed the same policy of oppressing and dispossessing Palestinians to make way for an exclusively Jewish state. Even now, when Israel could have peace and security for the asking, Israeli governments persist in their original intention of conquering the whole of Palestine for the use of the Jewish people alone. And all this was done, and is still being done, by Jews, for Jews and in the name of Jews.”

The group lists, among the many people it calls 'Our Initial List of Righteous Jews', Albert Einstein, Amira Hass, Anna Baltzer, Antony Loewenstein, Gideon Levy, the late Hedy Epstein, Ilan Pappe, Jeff Halper, Jennifer Lowenstein, Lenni Brenner, Miko Peled, Norman Finkelstein, Richard Falk, Tanya Reinhart and the late Yehudi Menuhin. All have worked to expose the evils of the practise and ideology of political Zionism.

Elizabeth Morley (several of whose relatives died in the Holocaust) of the Palestine Solidarity Campaign in Aberystwyth, Wales, wrote the following to a pro-Zionist UK MP:

Is it not ironic that millions of Jews from all around the world are invited to claim Israeli citizenship, even if they end up, not in Israel, but in an illegal settlement on Palestinian land? With my Jewish heritage I too could claim Israeli citizenship. How ridiculous is that!

Although I have a good life here in the UK I could go over there and make use of the privileges that are denied to the Palestinians whose land I would be occupying. I might even be given the house and possessions of a Palestinian family freshly displaced from East Jerusalem. And all the time the Palestinian refugees, turfed out to make room for me and millions like me, are mouldering in refugee camps.”

Speak truth to power

It is right and necessary that Holocaust denial, along with all forms of misleading, racist propaganda, be challenged, preferably through the presentation of the verifiable evidence to the contrary that is so easily accessible. But when the Zionist Lobby makes use of the Holocaust to divert attention away from Israel's violations of international law, that also must be challenged. Unrestrained political Zionism threatens the very survival of the tragically hard-won Fourth Geneva Convention and undermines the principle of respect for international humanitarian law. For too long, our political leaders and spokespersons have avoided calling Israel to account. Surrendering reason to ideology brings nothing but tragedy. New Zealand's sponsorship of UNSCR 2334 should signal a determined change of heart and direction – and greater hope for humanity.


The Palestine Yearbook 2015

The genocide the world ignores

by Diana Lodge

Everyone should have a copy

of this invaluable resource!

To order the book:


See this In Occupied Palestine newsletter at: the PHRC website:

- and you can check out previous editions by clicking on In Occupied Palestine listed under Contents


Let us know if you no longer wish to receive these emails. Please, if you have friends or family who would like to receive them ask them to contact us at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it